top of page
Search

Executive Staffing Trends That Reduce Turnover in Property Management

Writer:  EPS Team
EPS Team
Jan 13
11 min read

Updated: Oct 31

Employee retention is an important consideration for commercial real estate owners, multifamily operators, REITs, and property management companies.


When experienced Property Managers, Regional Managers, Directors, and executive leaders remain with an organization, they can provide continuity in property operations, employee supervision, tenant relationships, financial reporting, and portfolio management.


However, reducing turnover requires more than offering competitive compensation or filling vacancies quickly.


Employers must understand why experienced property management professionals change positions, what motivates them to remain with an organization, and how leadership decisions influence employee satisfaction.


The most effective property management executive staffing strategies focus on hiring qualified leaders whose experience, compensation expectations, career goals, and management responsibilities align with the employer's long-term objectives.


This article examines executive recruiting trends that can support employee retention, reduce unnecessary leadership transitions, and help real estate employers build more stable property management teams.


Executive Staffing Trends That Reduce Turnover in Property Management

Why Employee Retention Matters in Property Management

Property management is a relationship-driven business.


Managers work closely with property owners, tenants, residents, vendors, contractors, maintenance teams, and corporate leadership.


When an experienced manager leaves, the organization may need to redistribute responsibilities while recruiting and training a replacement.


Potential effects include:

  • Additional recruiting expenses.

  • Increased workload for existing employees.

  • Interrupted tenant or resident communication.

  • Delayed operational decisions.

  • Loss of property-specific knowledge.

  • Changes in vendor relationships.

  • Disruption to financial reporting.

  • Additional employee training requirements.


The extent of disruption depends on the position, property type, team structure, and transition plan.


For employers, retaining effective leadership supports operational continuity and reduces the frequency of replacement hiring.


Property Management Employment and Leadership Demand

According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, employment of property, real estate, and community association managers is projected to grow 4% from 2024 to 2034.


The BLS also projects approximately 39,000 annual job openings, on average, over that period, including openings associated with workers leaving the occupation or transferring to other occupations.



These projections cover the broader occupation, not executive positions exclusively.


They provide useful context for employers planning long-term property management recruitment and workforce development.


8 Executive Staffing Trends That Support Employee Retention


1. Recruiting Based on Career Motivation, Not Just Experience

Traditional recruiting often emphasizes job titles, years of experience, and technical qualifications.


While these factors remain important, employers should also understand what motivates a candidate to consider a new opportunity.


Experienced property management professionals may prioritize:

  • Career advancement.

  • Compensation.

  • Leadership responsibilities.

  • Portfolio size.

  • Organizational stability.

  • Geographic location.

  • Workload.

  • Management support.

  • Professional development.


A candidate interested in moving into regional leadership may not remain satisfied in a position offering limited advancement.


Likewise, a Regional Manager seeking a smaller portfolio may not be interested in returning to extensive multi-state travel.


Retention-focused recruiting begins by understanding whether the opportunity supports the candidate's professional goals.


2. Matching Candidates to Actual Portfolio Responsibilities

Property management titles do not always reflect the complexity of a position.


A Regional Manager responsible for 1,000 units may have different responsibilities from a Regional Manager overseeing 5,000 units across several states.


Similarly, a Commercial Property Manager overseeing a single Class A office tower may have different operational requirements from a manager responsible for multiple retail and industrial properties.


Recruiters should evaluate:

  • Property type.

  • Portfolio size.

  • Unit count or square footage.

  • Number of properties.

  • Operating budgets.

  • Employee supervision.

  • Geographic coverage.

  • Capital project responsibilities.

  • Reporting relationships.


Candidates should understand these responsibilities before accepting an offer.


Clear expectations help employers and candidates make more informed hiring decisions.


3. Greater Emphasis on Compensation Alignment

Compensation remains an important factor in recruiting and retaining experienced property management professionals.


However, salary alone does not determine whether a candidate will remain with an organization.


Employers should consider the complete compensation package, including:

  • Base salary.

  • Performance bonuses.

  • Benefits.

  • Retirement contributions.

  • Paid time off.

  • Travel requirements.

  • Professional development opportunities.

  • Advancement potential.


A position offering a higher salary may be less attractive if it requires substantially more travel, a larger portfolio, or significantly greater responsibilities.


Recruiters should discuss compensation expectations early in the process to identify potential misalignment.


4. Direct Headhunting of Experienced Property Management Leaders

Experienced property management executives may be currently employed and not actively applying for positions.


Direct headhunting allows employers to reach professionals who may consider a new opportunity when it aligns with their career objectives.


A targeted search may focus on candidates with experience in:

  • Comparable property types.

  • Similar portfolio sizes.

  • Relevant geographic markets.

  • Financial management.

  • Employee leadership.

  • Operational improvements.


Recruiters should evaluate a candidate's interest and motivation rather than assuming that a currently employed professional is automatically more qualified or more likely to remain in a new role.


5. Behavioral and Situational Interviewing

Employers are increasingly focused on understanding how candidates respond to real operational challenges.


Behavioral interviews can help evaluate leadership judgment, communication, and problem-solving.


Examples include:

  • How have you handled employee turnover at a property?

  • Describe a situation where you improved team communication.

  • How do you respond when an employee is consistently underperforming?

  • What steps have you taken to develop an Assistant Property Manager into a leadership role?

  • How have you managed competing priorities across multiple properties?


Candidates should provide specific examples of their responsibilities, decisions, and results.


6. Evaluating Leadership Development Experience

Property management executives influence the experience of employees who report to them.


Regional Managers, Directors, and Vice Presidents often supervise Community Managers, Property Managers, and other operational leaders.


Employers should evaluate whether candidates have experience with:

  • Employee coaching.

  • Performance management.

  • Training.

  • Career development.

  • Succession planning.

  • Team communication.

  • Conflict resolution.


Gallup has reported that managers account for a substantial portion of the variance in employee engagement across business units.



This research is not specific to property management and does not establish a direct reduction in employee turnover.


However, it reinforces the importance of evaluating management capabilities when selecting leaders.


7. Realistic Job Expectations Before Hiring

A common source of hiring misalignment is a difference between the advertised position and the actual responsibilities.


Employers should clearly communicate:

  • Portfolio size.

  • Property conditions.

  • Reporting structure.

  • Team size.

  • Travel expectations.

  • Operating challenges.

  • Performance objectives.

  • Compensation.

  • Available support resources.


For example, a Regional Manager joining an organization with several distressed communities should understand the operational requirements before accepting the position.


Transparent communication helps candidates determine whether the opportunity matches their experience and career objectives.


8. Stronger Leadership Succession Planning

Property management companies can support operational continuity by preparing employees for future leadership responsibilities.


Succession planning may include:

  • Identifying high-potential employees.

  • Developing Assistant Property Managers.

  • Preparing Community Managers for regional positions.

  • Training Regional Managers for director-level responsibilities.

  • Documenting operational procedures.

  • Establishing leadership transition plans.


Executive recruiting and internal leadership development can complement each other.


External recruiting may be appropriate when an organization requires specialized experience or additional leadership capacity.


Which Property Management Positions Benefit Most From Retention-Focused Recruiting?

Several positions have significant influence over property operations and employee leadership.

Position

Retention-Related Responsibilities

Community Manager

Onsite team leadership, resident relations, daily operations

Commercial Property Manager

Tenant communication, vendor relationships, building operations

Regional Property Manager

Multi-property oversight, manager development, operational consistency

Director of Property Management

Regional leadership, operating standards, organizational performance

Vice President of Operations

Executive oversight, leadership strategy, portfolio performance

Facilities Director

Engineering leadership, maintenance continuity, technical operations

Asset Manager

Ownership reporting, investment objectives, asset strategy

Employers should prioritize retention strategies according to the responsibilities and organizational importance of each position.


How Retention Strategies Differ by Property Type


Multifamily Property Management

Multifamily teams manage leasing, resident relations, collections, maintenance, and onsite operations.


Retention-focused recruiting should evaluate candidates' experience with:

  • Employee supervision.

  • Occupancy management.

  • Resident communication.

  • Maintenance coordination.

  • Operating budgets.

  • Portfolio complexity.


For Regional Managers, employers should assess how candidates develop and support onsite teams.


Commercial Office Properties

Commercial Property Managers often maintain relationships with tenants, engineers, vendors, and ownership representatives.


Relevant qualifications include:

  • Tenant relations.

  • Building operations.

  • Financial reporting.

  • Vendor management.

  • Capital projects.

  • Engineering coordination.


Leadership continuity can help maintain institutional knowledge and established operating relationships.


Retail Property Management

Retail managers may oversee shopping centers, tenant coordination, maintenance, and common area operations.


Employers should evaluate:

  • Retail asset experience.

  • Tenant communication.

  • Vendor relationships.

  • Budget management.

  • Capital improvements.

  • Multi-property responsibilities.


Industrial Property Management

Industrial Property Managers may oversee logistics facilities, warehouses, and distribution properties.


Relevant experience includes:

  • Industrial building operations.

  • Tenant requirements.

  • Maintenance coordination.

  • Capital projects.

  • Vendor management.

  • Financial reporting.


HOA and Condominium Management

HOA managers work closely with association boards and homeowners.


Retention-focused recruiting should consider:

  • Board relations.

  • Association governance.

  • Community communication.

  • Budgeting.

  • Reserve planning.

  • Applicable licensing.

  • Conflict resolution.


The best retention strategy depends on the position's actual responsibilities and operating environment.


How to Identify Property Management Leaders Who Can Develop Stable Teams

Employers should ask candidates to explain how they have managed employee retention and team development.


Evaluate Previous Leadership Responsibilities

Determine:

  • Number of direct reports.

  • Types of employees supervised.

  • Properties or regions managed.

  • Hiring responsibilities.

  • Training responsibilities.


Ask About Employee Development

Candidates should provide examples of coaching employees and preparing them for advancement.


Review Management Practices

Ask how candidates communicate expectations, address performance concerns, and resolve conflicts.


Discuss Career Motivation

Understand why the candidate is considering the position and what they expect from the employer.


Verify Relevant Experience

Professional references can provide additional insight into leadership responsibilities and management performance.


A candidate's tenure should be considered in context rather than treated as a guarantee of future retention.


Property Management Executive Retention Scorecard

Employers can use a structured evaluation framework during interviews.

Evaluation Category

Suggested Weight

Relevant property management experience

25%

Leadership and employee development

25%

Career motivation and opportunity alignment

20%

Operational and financial management

15%

Communication and problem-solving

10%

Geographic and travel alignment

5%

Total

100%

These weights are illustrative.


For a Facilities Director, technical leadership may deserve greater emphasis.


For a Regional Property Manager, team development and multi-community oversight may be more important.


Employers should apply consistent, job-related criteria and avoid making assumptions based solely on career history.


10 Interview Questions That Support Retention-Focused Hiring

  1. Why are you considering a new opportunity?

  2. What responsibilities are most important in your next position?

  3. Describe how you have developed employees into leadership roles.

  4. What management practices have helped you build effective teams?

  5. How have you handled employee turnover within your portfolio?

  6. What type of organizational support helps you perform effectively?

  7. Describe a challenging property or portfolio you managed.

  8. What are your expectations regarding travel and geographic responsibilities?

  9. What professional goals would you like to accomplish over the next three years?

  10. What factors would make this position a strong long-term career opportunity?


These questions help employers evaluate both qualifications and the candidate's expectations.


What Does Property Management Leadership Turnover Cost?

Replacing an experienced Property Manager or Regional Manager can involve several expenses.


Potential costs include:

  • Recruiting fees.

  • Internal recruiting time.

  • Interview expenses.

  • Training.

  • Temporary redistribution of responsibilities.

  • Reduced productivity during transition.

  • Additional employee workload.


There is no single turnover cost percentage that accurately applies to every property management position.


Employers should calculate the cost according to their own organization and the responsibilities of the vacant position.


Illustrative Leadership Turnover Cost

Consider a hypothetical Regional Property Manager position.

Cost Category

Estimated Cost

Recruitment expenses

$30,000

Internal hiring and interview time

$4,000

Training and transition

$6,000

Additional operating coverage

$8,000

Total Estimated Replacement Cost

$48,000

This example is hypothetical and should not be interpreted as an industry average.


Actual costs depend on compensation, recruiting arrangements, vacancy duration, and operational circumstances.


It demonstrates why employers may benefit from evaluating retention alongside recruiting expenses.


How to Measure Employee Retention in Property Management

Property management companies can monitor workforce stability using several indicators.

KPI

What It Measures

Annual employee turnover rate

Percentage of employees who leave during a defined period

Voluntary turnover rate

Employee-initiated departures

Leadership retention rate

Percentage of leaders remaining over a defined period

Average employee tenure

Length of service

First-year retention

Employees remaining after 12 months

Internal promotion rate

Leadership positions filled through employee advancement

Vacancy duration

Time positions remain unfilled

Employee engagement

Workforce feedback and engagement trends

These indicators should be reviewed alongside compensation, organizational changes, market conditions, and employee feedback.


No single metric can fully explain why employees remain or leave.


How to Calculate Property Management Employee Retention

A basic employee retention formula is:


Employee Retention Rate = (Employees Who Remained During the Period ÷ Employees at the Start of the Period) × 100


For example, assume a property management company begins the year with 100 employees.


If 90 of those original employees remain at year-end:


90 ÷ 100 × 100 = 90% retention.


This calculation excludes employees hired after the beginning of the measurement period.


Employers should use consistent definitions when comparing retention rates over time.


How Property Management Companies Can Improve First-Year Retention

Recruiting is only one part of employee retention.


After hiring, employers should establish clear expectations and provide appropriate support.


Before the Start Date

Confirm:

  • Position responsibilities.

  • Reporting relationships.

  • Compensation.

  • Travel requirements.

  • Performance expectations.


During the First 30 Days

The employer should introduce the new leader to:

  • Employees.

  • Ownership representatives.

  • Operating procedures.

  • Property budgets.

  • Portfolio priorities.


During the First 90 Days

Leadership should review:

  • Operational responsibilities.

  • Team performance.

  • Property conditions.

  • Financial reporting.

  • Initial objectives.


During the First Year

Employers should provide ongoing feedback, clarify expectations, and discuss professional development.


These employer-led practices can support a more organized leadership transition.


When Should Employers Use an Executive Search Firm to Improve Hiring Alignment?

Specialized executive recruiting may be valuable when:


  • A leadership position requires specific asset class experience.

  • The employer is expanding into new markets.

  • A Regional Manager or Director position is difficult to fill.

  • The organization needs experienced passive candidates.

  • The position involves substantial financial responsibility.

  • The employer is replacing a senior leader.

  • Internal recruiting resources are limited.


An executive search firm should help identify candidates whose qualifications and expectations match the position.


However, no recruiting process can guarantee employee retention.


Long-term outcomes depend on both the hiring decision and the employer's ongoing management practices.


How Executive Property Staffing Supports Retention-Focused Executive Recruiting

Executive Property Staffing, LLC provides nationwide direct-hire recruiting and executive search for commercial real estate, property management, multifamily, asset management, facilities management, and related leadership positions.


We recruit professionals for positions including:

  • Regional Property Manager.

  • Director of Property Management.

  • Vice President of Operations.

  • Commercial Property Manager.

  • General Manager.

  • Asset Manager.

  • Facilities Director.

  • Senior Property Management Executive.


Our recruiting approach emphasizes targeted LinkedIn research, direct headhunting, and evaluating candidates according to relevant industry experience.


We consider:

  • Asset class.

  • Portfolio size.

  • Operational responsibilities.

  • Financial management.

  • Leadership experience.

  • Compensation expectations.

  • Career motivation.

  • Geographic requirements.


Our objective is to present qualified candidates whose professional backgrounds and career goals align with the employer's hiring requirements.


EPS specializes in permanent placement rather than temporary or contract staffing.


Frequently Asked Questions About Executive Staffing and Property Management Turnover


How can executive staffing reduce turnover in property management?

Retention-focused executive staffing can help employers identify candidates whose experience, career goals, compensation expectations, and leadership capabilities align with the position. Employers must also provide appropriate management support and career development.


What causes Property Managers and Regional Managers to leave?

Reasons vary but may include compensation, workload, career advancement, travel requirements, management support, organizational changes, and personal circumstances.


What should employers look for in property management executives?

Employers should evaluate relevant property management experience, financial responsibility, team leadership, communication, operational knowledge, and career motivation.


Does hiring passive candidates improve employee retention?

Passive candidates may provide access to experienced professionals, but employment status alone does not predict retention. Candidate motivation and opportunity alignment remain important.


How can multifamily companies improve Regional Manager retention?

Employers can establish realistic portfolio responsibilities, competitive compensation, clear expectations, leadership support, and professional development opportunities.


What is a good employee retention rate for property management?

There is no universal retention target appropriate for every property management organization. Employers should evaluate historical performance, position type, market conditions, and relevant industry benchmarks.


How should employers measure executive retention?

Common measures include first-year retention, leadership tenure, voluntary turnover, employee engagement, and internal promotion rates.


Can specialized property management recruiters help with executive succession?

Yes. Specialized recruiters can help employers identify external candidates when leadership transitions or organizational growth require additional experience.


Does Executive Property Staffing provide nationwide executive recruiting?

Yes. EPS provides nationwide direct-hire recruiting and executive search for commercial real estate and property management leadership positions.


Build Stable Property Management Teams Through Better Executive Hiring

Employee retention begins with informed hiring decisions.


For commercial real estate owners, multifamily operators, REITs, and property management companies, recruiting experienced leaders requires careful evaluation of professional qualifications, career motivation, compensation, leadership capabilities, and portfolio responsibilities.


Specialized executive search can help employers identify professionals who are well suited to their positions and organizational objectives.


Executive Property Staffing, LLC provides nationwide property management executive search, direct-hire recruiting, and specialized headhunting.


We help employers identify Regional Managers, Directors, Vice Presidents, Asset Managers, Commercial Property Managers, and other experienced real estate leaders.


Contact Executive Property Staffing to discuss your permanent property management hiring requirements.


Phone: 949-346-1618

Comments


bottom of page